Common Reasons Rental Applications Get Rejected (And How to Avoid Them)

Do you want to apply for a rental area, but there’s a fear of getting rejected? Have your previous applications been rejected? Don’t stress out. It often happens, but the causes are almost always the same.

We agree that this process is not easy. There might be an issue with your application. Perhaps you were only late to apply. The landlord has already decided on any other candidate. If you are tired of seeing rejection emails, let us help you.

We will show you the most common reasons that cause rejection. You can fix almost all of these problems with some tricks. What are you waiting for? Start reading below!

Rental Application

1. Your Credit Score Is Too Low

The first thing a landlord will check is your credit score. A low score means immediate rejection. The person does not even bother to read the next documents. They do not consider you trustworthy, so they cannot rent their space to you. They believe that you were not good with the previous payments.

Landlords will only rent their apartment or home if they trust you. Your credit history should be positive and show your professionalism. A credit score less than 620 is considered a negative aspect. A bad score basically shows that you have struggled with bills before. They don’t know your story, but they rely on these numbers.

Are you thinking about how to improve your credit score? The first thing is to check the score on any reliable platform. See if there are any errors. Incorrect or outdated information and red flags.

Let’s come to a major part: what happens if your credit score is low? It means the application has high chances of getting rejected. You should pay more attention to private landlords instead of renting a bigger home. Their owners are often more open to a real conversation with you.

2. Your Income is Less

Landlords follow a 3x rule. This implies that your income should be 3 times the rent of the area. If an apartment rents for $1,200 a month, your income should be more than $3600.

People often fail at this stage. You might be earning more than this, but sometimes you cannot prove it. The situation is more difficult for freelancers and independent workers.

They cannot prove their income because they get paid from multiple sources.  Independent workers do not have a regular pay stub. Some people get cash, so their bank statement does not show the salary. The challenge is proving your income on paper.

You should collect your documents in one place before applying. Find recent pay stubs rather than old ones. Your bank statements should indicate regular deposits. It’s good to ask the manager to pay your salary into your bank account rather than in cash.

You can also prove the income by showing your employment letter or a contract with the company. People often show the tax returns for the previous two years.

You have to prove to the landlord that you get enough payment to pay the rent easily. They trust in you if our usual bills are paid on time each month. Use a utility bill generator to organize these documents.

3. Problems With Your Rental History

Landlords often call your old landlords to investigate you. These calls can go a ton of different ways, but it really comes down to how you left things.

You may face issues if you’ve ever quit without notice, owe money, or had an unresolved dispute. That’s definitely going to become a hurdle. Some landlords give neutral, half-hearted references.

Call your previous landlords yourself before you apply anywhere. Find out where things stand. If there’s something that appears to be a problem, fix it. A landlord who settles a bill with you is much more likely to give you one that will be favourable.

Now, let’s talk about having no rental history at all, if you’re renting for the first time! In this case, you have to share extra documents at the start. It can be an employer reference or a short letter of introduction about yourself. Any verifiable document can fill the gap.

4. A Background Check Has a Hit on You

Policies for criminal history are all over the place. People may automatically decline the application if your name is found on the criminal records. Some may not automatically decline the application. They analyze what the offense was and how old it is.

Evictions are typically the greater dealbreaker. An eviction that is 3-4 years old will cause most landlords to move on without thinking.

You should run a background check on yourself. You can use something like Checkr or SmartMove. See what a landlord will see. Prepare your explanation if you notice any eviction.

At the same time, several cities and states have enacted fair-chance housing policies that restrict your record from being used against you by landlords in certain ways. Check the local rules and regulations.

5. Your Application Seems Rushed 

This one surprises people. The landlord will glean something about you as a tenant before you’ve even moved in. The format and appearance of your application are important. Incomplete documents or blurry copies of your ID are not preferred.

Landlords are busy. If your application is difficult for them to process, they go on to the next one. Other landlords request more specific items, such as references in a certain format, evidence of renter’s insurance, and a cover letter. Provide them with exactly what they ordered.

Complete all fields even if they seem optional. You should share professional and legible copies of everything. It adds another 20 minutes, but you cannot neglect it.

6. Someone Else Got There First

Sometimes, the rejection is not about your application at all. Good apartments get 30 or 40 applications on the first day, if your city is competitive. The authorities close the first fully qualified person.

The solution to this is speed. You have to prepare everything before you start looking for rental homes. Immediately assemble a rental folder. It should include your ID, two or three recent pay stubs, and your bank statements.

You can also add references with their contact info and a short introduction of yourself. This means it’s easier to apply on the same day. You do not have to rush for documents when you find a place you want.

Some renters even prepare a simple one-page renter’s resume. It highlights their income, brief rental history, and a few lines about them. This is something that helps in a tight rental market.

7. Your References Didn’t Help You

Landlords call references. If your reference doesn’t get back to them, or is vague in their response, or says something that clashes with your application, it’s a red flag.

People sometimes write names down and anticipate it all falling into place. You should contact your references before you start sending applications. Let them know that a landlord may reach out.

Mention what you’d want them to mention. They should talk about your reliability and trustworthiness. References from work are more valuable than personal references. There is nothing more convincing than an employer or manager who can speak to your responsibility.

What To Do If You’ve Already Been Denied?

Ask why. A handful of landlords wouldn’t say that to you, but the majority will. This is the most valuable information you need. This will be useful in the future. Credit issue? Work on it. Income documentation? Get organized. References? Reach out to them now. The rental market favors the prepared and amenable. You should have organized comments and a good history to be accepted.